Reviews
Playdate
Movies like Playdate don’t just make me question why I chose to become a film critic, they make me question my actual existence. Within the opening scene I knew exactly what I was in for, and it turned out to be among the most painful 90 minutes I have endured this year, and that includes the time I broke my finger. It’s no wonder people say the comedy genre is dying when films like Playdate exist. It’s an embarrassing, humourless heap of cinematic slop I would not wish on my worst enemy.
The movie follows the hapless Brian (Kevin James), a wildly pathetic, recently fired forensic accountant who now has to play stay-at-home dad while his wife Emily (Sarah Chalke) goes back to work to make ends meet. In an attempt to connect with his frequently bullied, dance-loving stepson Lucas (Benjamin Pajak), Brian turns to sports to “toughen him up” and, without ever explicitly saying so, make him more “manly.” Enter ex-soldier Jeff (Alan Ritchson), a mountain of a man with his equally chaotic son CJ (Banks Pierce), who instantly suggests a playdate on the spot, because that is not weird at all. Rather than acting like a responsible parent, Brian agrees and chaos ensues.
As the playdate inevitably goes south, and fast, Brian and the rest of the gang encounter a group of mercenaries who seem to be hunting Jeff and CJ. This could have been the moment for genuinely thrilling action sequences that might have salvaged the film. Instead, we are treated to some of the worst action scenes of the year, plagued by sloppy choreography, jarring camera work, and zero excitement. To make matters worse, the whole thing feels like an extended advertisement for the Honda Odyssey, as Brian and Jeff repeatedly use it as the world’s most durable getaway vehicle. They are pursued by cops, mercenaries, and a baffling mum mafia led by Isla Fisher, all of whom, of course, also drive Honda Odysseys. I can only assume writer Neil Goldman thought this was a hilarious addition, but it is cringe inducing from the outset.
As Luke Greenfield’s sloppy-at-best screenplay unravels, the film barrels toward the most obvious twist about who CJ really is, becoming increasingly tiresome and irritating. There is a poorly executed attempt to make the audience feel something during the final, shockingly violent scenes, which seem to be chasing the energy of the Kingsman films. Where those sequences worked in Kingsman because of clever setup and confident direction, in Playdate they are laughably bad and completely misplaced. By the end, the only feeling left is an overwhelming sense of “what did I just watch?”
To have a comedic actor of Kevin James’ calibre, who has a direct route to my funny bone with Paul Blart: Mall Cop being one of my favourite guilty pleasures, and make him this unfunny, is almost a phenomenon worthy of study. Whether it is purely the writing or a combination of writing and directing is up for debate, but in Playdate he is nauseatingly unfunny. Some of the humour might prompt a vocal minority to call people “woke” for not finding it funny, but the level of toilet humour on display may have worked in the 1990s. Here, it is the most tragic attempt at comedy I have seen all year. Ritchson is largely innocent; he does the best with what he is given as a macho, no-nonsense alpha male, but the character itself is so poorly written that even his efforts cannot save it.
The film also commits a criminal use of ADR that gives even the dreadful Madame Web a run for its money. In fact, the only laughs I experienced came during the action sequences, where characters seem to be talking without their lips moving at all, making this the ugliest use of the technology I have seen all year. At times I genuinely questioned whether what I was watching was real or some early AI-generated video, because surely the egregious nature of the ADR would have been noticed during editing. Clearly, it was not.
Usually, I try to find at least one positive to hold onto. I love films and want to inspire even one reader to watch the movie in question. With Playdate, that is simply impossible. There is not a single element of the film I can confidently say works even remotely well. The fact is, when audiences complain that the comedy genre is dying, films like Playdate are exactly why. If you are even mildly curious about watching this movie, do yourself a favour: go outside, see some nature, say hello to a friend you have been meaning to contact, do ANYTHING at all other than watching Playdate.
